Post by Jason on Jun 16, 2009 15:58:41 GMT 10
Alright, let's just get this going. I'm just going to lay out my game for all to see and if you wanna pick it (or me) apart, feel free, whether it be nasty/constructive questions or statements! You know i'm ready to deal with them. <3
I played a good game and I'm just gonna tell you how it all went.
I joined this game because it didn't look complex and I also thought it wouldn't have any amount of stress/hatred in it. The board was done simply and it was the host's first game, so it seemed like a good choice.
Let's be honest - not much happened in this game until the merge. A few people quit and the idlers got voted out. I was with Jenna first and foremost and we had a F2 pact. I found myself liking both Heidi and Amanda (who were also paired off) and the 4 of us had what I think of as an unspoken alliance that we made official a few rounds into the game. I also talked to Shii Ann a fair amount, but I felt like I never trusted her (good intuition!)
Jenna and I always discussed what OUR best move in the game was and knew that we would have to split up Amanda/Heidi at some point, which we accomplished later on.
At merge, Shii Ann tried feeding our side junk about how she wanted Kel/Joe out, saying they were idlers that she didn't respect and she wanted the game to have the best jury possible. I didn't believe her and so I talked to Amanda about it, who originally intended to go along with this, but we decided to vote for Kel/Mia without telling her. I filled in Jenna and Amanda filled in Heidi.
Now here is something the majority of the jury would not know. Heidi didn't vote correctly either. She accidentally voted for Joe and then Kel, which were both stray votes that didn't matter. The reason the vote still tied was because Ian voted with us, and the reason he did so was because of me. I reached out to him and offered an alliance. So our set of 4 votes were from Jason/Amanda/Jenna/Ian. If Heidi voted correctly, we would have had majority, and if whoever on the other side didn't mess up either, it would have tied 5-5. My reaching out to Ian saved our asses and gave us a fighting chance.
Kel lost his tie to Amanda and I lost my tiebreaker to Mia. I made this comment about it on the TC 10 thread:
"i played a good game <3 i was never outplayed or outwitted.. i simply lost a tiebreak challenge to mia (which i would have won if i kept my original firecount). you can vote however you see fit, though, i don't mind."
and Mia responded with this:
You just contradicted yourself. You WERE outplayed...I beat you in that tie breaker challenge fair and square. Besides that...had the host been clearer in that vote to start with then our whole crew would've voted the right way and then BOTH you and Amanda would've simply been voted out. No ties involved.
I wasn't able to respond in that thread, but I'm going to do so now. I totally admit that I DID lose that fair and square, it's not about that. To me, the word "outplayed" means that I was beaten on a strategic level, which I don't feel I was. Losing the tiebreaker falls under "outlasted" to me, so it's really just a matter of semantics. As for the second part, we can throw ifs out all day, but it doesn't change what happened... and now that you know what you do about Heidi misvoting as well, we could have either won or still tied too.
Then I returned to the game. This is the part where some people take issue - but I had nothing to do with it and anyone could have won that prize. A bringback has happened on the show. Shii Ann has been most critical of this, but how come no one has complained about how ridiculous all the other powers the crates had were? Or how there were 3 hidden immunity idols in the game? (of which Shii Ann had 2, lol) I was "saved" by the bringback, but other people were saved by other things too - for example, Mia was saved by the power she had by piggybacking onto Shii Ann's immunity win, forcing us to vote out Ian. I take no issue with that because, in truth, the whole game was kind of ridiculous, haha. Given this, the final vote shouldn't be based around these powers and should be based on who played the best game.
In the vote where I came back, Amanda wanted to assure Shii Ann that we would not vote her out and do it anyway, thinking she would not play her idols and I basically had to tell her that she was crazy. I instead suggested that we make Shii Ann think for SURE she needed to play them and to blindside Ami, making Shii get rid of her idols and look stupid in the process, lol. Just being honest, I enjoyed that immensely! LOL. Jenna helped with this by telling Shii that she thought Mia/Ami were voting with us as well, which made her play BOTH instead of one since one of them had an HII disabling power. Jenna and I rocked that vote, not Amanda (sorry girl, just tellin' it!)
Then Joe quit and then we were forced to vote out Ian, who was a nice guy but that wasn't in our F4 alliance.
Then Shii Ann quit.
Then Jenna and I made another move and decided it was time to split up Heidi/Amanda. The reason we went for Heidi is because Amanda still had her HII, but we made sure they didn't have a strategic advantage over us. We did this by going to Mia, who was totally on board. This was when I got to know Mia/Bo on a better level, which I probably should have done before. You know I don't kiss ass, but Bo is a cool guy and I think that he would be in the F3 right now if he didn't tell me that he joined the game with Joe/Kel/Ami. Between them and Shii, that = auto-win. I knew it couldn't happen.
So I worked my ass off to win the final immunity to make sure Jenna and I got what we wanted and so that I'd have the final decision. Amanda and Jenna didn't even finish part 1. How could they want the win more than me if they didn't try very hard on the FINAL immunity?
And that's my game. Aside from all that, I just think that I was very visible in the game and that I was always very emotionally honest and was never afraid to speak my mind instead of riding the fence. I'm ok with not being the winner, but I hope I've made a pretty good case anyhow! Good luck to Jenna and Amanda <3
I played a good game and I'm just gonna tell you how it all went.
I joined this game because it didn't look complex and I also thought it wouldn't have any amount of stress/hatred in it. The board was done simply and it was the host's first game, so it seemed like a good choice.
Let's be honest - not much happened in this game until the merge. A few people quit and the idlers got voted out. I was with Jenna first and foremost and we had a F2 pact. I found myself liking both Heidi and Amanda (who were also paired off) and the 4 of us had what I think of as an unspoken alliance that we made official a few rounds into the game. I also talked to Shii Ann a fair amount, but I felt like I never trusted her (good intuition!)
Jenna and I always discussed what OUR best move in the game was and knew that we would have to split up Amanda/Heidi at some point, which we accomplished later on.
At merge, Shii Ann tried feeding our side junk about how she wanted Kel/Joe out, saying they were idlers that she didn't respect and she wanted the game to have the best jury possible. I didn't believe her and so I talked to Amanda about it, who originally intended to go along with this, but we decided to vote for Kel/Mia without telling her. I filled in Jenna and Amanda filled in Heidi.
Now here is something the majority of the jury would not know. Heidi didn't vote correctly either. She accidentally voted for Joe and then Kel, which were both stray votes that didn't matter. The reason the vote still tied was because Ian voted with us, and the reason he did so was because of me. I reached out to him and offered an alliance. So our set of 4 votes were from Jason/Amanda/Jenna/Ian. If Heidi voted correctly, we would have had majority, and if whoever on the other side didn't mess up either, it would have tied 5-5. My reaching out to Ian saved our asses and gave us a fighting chance.
Kel lost his tie to Amanda and I lost my tiebreaker to Mia. I made this comment about it on the TC 10 thread:
"i played a good game <3 i was never outplayed or outwitted.. i simply lost a tiebreak challenge to mia (which i would have won if i kept my original firecount). you can vote however you see fit, though, i don't mind."
and Mia responded with this:
You just contradicted yourself. You WERE outplayed...I beat you in that tie breaker challenge fair and square. Besides that...had the host been clearer in that vote to start with then our whole crew would've voted the right way and then BOTH you and Amanda would've simply been voted out. No ties involved.
I wasn't able to respond in that thread, but I'm going to do so now. I totally admit that I DID lose that fair and square, it's not about that. To me, the word "outplayed" means that I was beaten on a strategic level, which I don't feel I was. Losing the tiebreaker falls under "outlasted" to me, so it's really just a matter of semantics. As for the second part, we can throw ifs out all day, but it doesn't change what happened... and now that you know what you do about Heidi misvoting as well, we could have either won or still tied too.
Then I returned to the game. This is the part where some people take issue - but I had nothing to do with it and anyone could have won that prize. A bringback has happened on the show. Shii Ann has been most critical of this, but how come no one has complained about how ridiculous all the other powers the crates had were? Or how there were 3 hidden immunity idols in the game? (of which Shii Ann had 2, lol) I was "saved" by the bringback, but other people were saved by other things too - for example, Mia was saved by the power she had by piggybacking onto Shii Ann's immunity win, forcing us to vote out Ian. I take no issue with that because, in truth, the whole game was kind of ridiculous, haha. Given this, the final vote shouldn't be based around these powers and should be based on who played the best game.
In the vote where I came back, Amanda wanted to assure Shii Ann that we would not vote her out and do it anyway, thinking she would not play her idols and I basically had to tell her that she was crazy. I instead suggested that we make Shii Ann think for SURE she needed to play them and to blindside Ami, making Shii get rid of her idols and look stupid in the process, lol. Just being honest, I enjoyed that immensely! LOL. Jenna helped with this by telling Shii that she thought Mia/Ami were voting with us as well, which made her play BOTH instead of one since one of them had an HII disabling power. Jenna and I rocked that vote, not Amanda (sorry girl, just tellin' it!)
Then Joe quit and then we were forced to vote out Ian, who was a nice guy but that wasn't in our F4 alliance.
Then Shii Ann quit.
Then Jenna and I made another move and decided it was time to split up Heidi/Amanda. The reason we went for Heidi is because Amanda still had her HII, but we made sure they didn't have a strategic advantage over us. We did this by going to Mia, who was totally on board. This was when I got to know Mia/Bo on a better level, which I probably should have done before. You know I don't kiss ass, but Bo is a cool guy and I think that he would be in the F3 right now if he didn't tell me that he joined the game with Joe/Kel/Ami. Between them and Shii, that = auto-win. I knew it couldn't happen.
So I worked my ass off to win the final immunity to make sure Jenna and I got what we wanted and so that I'd have the final decision. Amanda and Jenna didn't even finish part 1. How could they want the win more than me if they didn't try very hard on the FINAL immunity?
And that's my game. Aside from all that, I just think that I was very visible in the game and that I was always very emotionally honest and was never afraid to speak my mind instead of riding the fence. I'm ok with not being the winner, but I hope I've made a pretty good case anyhow! Good luck to Jenna and Amanda <3